16 billion euros for around 160,000 apartments: The agreement reached during preliminary coalition talks in Berlin, between the Left Party (Die Linke), the Greens, and the Social Democratic Party (SPD), sets a financial framework for transferring large housing portfolios into social ownership. However, it remains unclear whether these figures are economically affordable for current owners, the future operator, and the state budget.
While the German newspaper BILD raises questions about the project’s financing through loans and rental income, former Vonovia board member Klaus Freiberg analyzes both sides of the proposal in a comment on LinkedIn: How much will the current owners actually benefit and how much money will remain with the new company to cover daily expenses?
In mathematical terms, the proposed compensation limit of 16 billion euros for 160,000 apartments equals 100,000 euros per apartment. Freiberg compares this amount to an estimated market value of around 170,000 euros per apartment.
Another issue is how the compensation will be carried out. The coalition’s preliminary document does not yet define this mechanism, while a financing plan is not expected to be drafted before 2027.
For this reason, Freiberg bases his analysis on the model outlined in the draft law of the initiative for housing socialization: the issuance of a bond with a 3.5% interest rate and a 100-year repayment term. These conditions have not yet been approved by the parties that could form a coalition.
The difference is important: compensation paid over several decades has a different economic value than an immediate payment.
According to Freiberg’s calculations, such a bond with a nominal value of 100,000 euros, based on the assumptions he used, would today have a real economic value of only 72,000 to 79,000 euros.
In fact, even after 50 years, about 85,000 euros from the initial debt would still remain unpaid.
Owners may receive much less than the value of the compensation
From the perspective of current owners, the existing financing of the properties must also be taken into account.
Freiberg argues that, in the case of transferring properties without mortgage encumbrances, the obligations guaranteed by mortgages must first be settled.
Taking as an example a debt ratio of 28%, which he cites for the company Deutsche Wohnen, Freiberg calculates that the remaining economic value for the owner would be only 24,000 to 31,000 euros per apartment.
Meanwhile, using the 46% debt ratio he cites for Vonovia, his model suggests that practically no economic value would remain for the owner.
However, he emphasizes that the group’s unsecured liabilities, such as the company’s bonds, would not be automatically transferred to the new entity along with the apartments.
The real consequences would depend on the specific financing structure and the relevant legal provisions.
Rental income may not be enough to pay off the debt
Freiberg’s calculations also suggest that the next housing operator would face very limited financial spaces.
Based on the average rent from Vonovia in Berlin, which is 8.26 euros per square meter per month, it drops to 3.73 euros per square meter for the costs of operating and managing the properties.
This would leave only 4.53 euros per square meter per month available for debt servicing.
On the other hand, the financing cost through the assumed bond is estimated at 4.94 euros per square meter.
The result is a deficit of 0.41 euros per square meter per month.
If the calculation were based on an initial rent of seven euros per square meter, as predicted in the study cited by Freiberg, the deficit would be even greater.
The upcoming financial plan must confirm these assumptions or present an alternative basis for the calculations.
The transfer of properties to the new operator requires additional funds and personnel
Besides financial risks, housing socialization also raises significant organizational problems.
As Freiberg points out, the transfer of land, buildings, and lease contracts does not automatically imply the creation of a functional system for housing management.
Maintenance workers, technical specialists, and emergency intervention services for heating systems will not be automatically available to the new operator.
The same applies to IT systems, billing data, and technical documentation.
For the transfer of these functions, binding agreements must be established in advance.
On the other hand, responsibility for services, security, and maintenance of the homes would begin from the very first day of operation.
Creating a new administrative structure would require additional funds and personnel, without bringing the construction of any new apartments.
“Funds would be better used for the construction of new housing”
“Socializing is the wrong approach. It commits considerable financial and human resources but does not create any additional housing. At the same time, management, maintenance, and modernization must be funded sustainably and long-term,” states Jacopo Mingazzini, the executive director of The Grounds.
According to him, a report from the Kiel Institute for the World Economy shows that the funds would be used more efficiently for building new homes.
In the analyzed scenarios, investments in new constructions would bring a significant slowdown in the growth of demanded rents in the market, requiring a comparable level of financing.
“Policymakers need to facilitate new construction and mobilize investments. This would also help those citizens who have so far unsuccessfully sought housing,” concludes Mingazzini./Adapted from The Groundsag, ekofin.al
