An unexpected piece of good news: Moody’s has left France’s sovereign debt rating unchanged. Although markets widely expected a downgrade, the New York-based agency decided on Friday evening to keep it at the Aa3 level, with a downside outlook.
The interest rate on France’s ten-year borrowing rate (OAT) has risen significantly this week, as the country faces tensions following the October 17 unrest, which have heightened investor concerns.
However, in a statement, Moody’s justified its decision by explaining that “the Aa3 rating is based on the assumption that a 2027 budget will be approved that reduces the deficit, while financing costs and social tensions will ease somewhat in the coming months.”
As soon as the announcement was made public, the government rushed to welcome the decision. The Minister of Economy, Roland Lescure, was the first to respond. He considers this decision as a “recognition of the strength of our economy and the credibility of the budget” presented by the government.
According to him, the goal of approving a “responsible” budget by the end of the year, which reduces the deficit to 5%, is “non-negotiable.”
In a more defensive tone, Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu welcomed on the X network the fact that Moody’s decision “dismisses the pessimistic forecasts of many ‘experts'” – the quotation marks are his – “and those who speculate with French debt.”
According to the head of government, the current debate on the budget in the National Assembly “shows our creditors that there is a way forward.”
He also pointed out a measure that, according to him, demonstrates the seriousness of the current economic policy: “With the release of 10 million barrels of diesel oil on the market, we will influence fuel pump prices from November 1st, without playing with public finances.”
“A welcome surprise”
A tougher stance from Moody’s, however, seemed inevitable. In an interview with Euronews, just a few hours before the decision, Théophile Legrand, an interest rate strategist at Natixis, considered the rating downgrade as the “baseline” scenario.
However, he emphasized that such a cut would have been “largely anticipated” by the markets and that the announcement, consequently, might not trigger a strong reaction on its own.
The final decision is “a welcome short-term surprise for the government and the markets,” notes the Natixis expert, part of the BPCE banking group, after the announcement was made.
However, this relatively tolerant approach should not be interpreted as a vote of confidence in the performance of public finances, he warns. Moody’s “maintains a negative outlook, meaning that the risk of downgrade remains fully present.”
“Moody’s appears to be giving France more time to demonstrate its ability to approve a credible budget for 2027 and begin deficit reduction.”
“The French government’s debt has become a true exclusion from the markets”
This had not happened since 2002. On Wednesday, France’s ten-year borrowing interest rate surpassed the 5.1% threshold, compared to 3.2% before the war between the United States and Iran began. The latter was already considered a high rate.
“This sharp drop in bond prices is undoubtedly bringing negative consequences for the French economy,” recalls Jérémie Peloso, who speaks of “particularly painful” consequences for the real estate market, as obtaining loans is becoming increasingly difficult.
“The French government debt market has become a true exception,” argues the economist.
“The reason is simple and has been known to everyone for years: French public finances are on an unsustainable trajectory.”
To this situation, he continues, is added the return of inflation against the backdrop of war in the Middle East, weak economic growth in France, and expectations for base interest rate hikes by the European Central Bank (ECB).
Jérémie Peloso does not rule out the possibility that, in the short term and considering the sharp rise in interest rates in recent days, buyers will opportunistically return to French OAT bonds, following the logic of “buy when the price falls.”
According to him, this development may be supported by losses recorded in stock markets, which could encourage investments to shift towards bonds, traditionally considered safe assets during periods of uncertainty.
This week, some French stocks fell on the stock market. Carrefour’s stock price fell by more than 13%, as the group estimated that the cost of the October 17 looting would range from 80 to 200 million euros.
In the luxury sector, Kering experienced a 16% decline, while Hermès fell by 7%, at a time when quarterly results were weaker and stores were damaged by acts of violence during the protests. This constitutes an additional vulnerability factor that worries investors.
However, investors turning to bonds “must not forget that French debt remains a real ticking time bomb,” insists Jérémie Peloso.
“Especially now that, after less than six months, presidential elections are approaching, which are expected to be extremely tense,” he adds.
As this date approaches, the political and social climate is very likely to deteriorate further, fueling new tensions in the French financial markets.
“Ultimately, the most concerning issue remains the pronounced lack of political will to seriously address budget imbalances,” says the expert, emphasizing that “none of the main parties” seems willing to accept the political cost of drastic spending cuts.
“As long as this situation does not change, investors will find it very difficult to regain confidence in French debt.”
“A crisis of confidence specific to France”
For Jérôme Mathis, professor of economics at Paris-Dauphine University and author of the blog “Finance at the Heart of Our Lives,” the most concerning signal is not the absolute level of interest rates, but the widening gap between them and Germany’s rates.
“The recent weakening of French bonds compared to German government bonds (Bund) mainly reflects a crisis of confidence specific to France,” he assesses.
“The United States is also borrowing at rates close to 5%, which shows that high rates are not inherently an anomaly. But when Germany stands close to 3.4%, while France surpasses 5.1%, it means that investors are seeking a specific risk premium for France.”
According to the expert, for a long time French government bonds (OAT) were considered almost equivalent to German Bund bonds.
“This assumption no longer holds today. This is the clearest indicator of the loss of budgetary and political credibility, and perhaps the most serious warning France has received since the sovereign debt crisis in Europe,” he states.
With the mobilization of high school students and protesters from the “Yellow Vests” movement, investors now fear that “any serious effort to restore balance to public finances will face strong social and political opposition,” notes Jérôme Mathis.
“If the markets conclude that a significant budget consolidation in France is not politically feasible, the risk premium demanded by investors could continue to rise.”
The battle over the budget in Parliament is becoming fiercer every day. On Friday, the Minister of Public Accounts and Civil Service, David Amiel, sharply criticized what he called the “fourth dimension” in the National Assembly.
“Billions of euros are being handed out abundantly and savings are mechanically hidden amid applause,” he complained, “while interest rates are rising significantly.”
The minister expressed particular concern over the fact that the social security deficit has “worsened by more than 5 billion euros” since the start of the draft law’s review, particularly highlighting the National Rassemblement.
Jérôme Mathis recalls that markets have already shown their sensitivity to “political scenarios that could call into question the state’s financial commitments.”
During the 2022 presidential campaign, Jean-Luc Mélenchon’s rise in the polls was accompanied, according to him, by “an increase in concerns about the future of French debt,” linked to his plan to cancel part of it.
“And now we are seeing the same combination”: the possibility of a second round of elections between Marine Le Pen and Jean-Luc Mélenchon, as well as the continuation of the LFI candidate’s proposal to cancel the portion of public debt held by the European Central Bank, or to convert it into permanent zero-interest debt. /Adapted from Euronews, ekofin.al
