Albania has made significant progress in the digitalization of public services, but the information provided to citizens about how these services operate remains insufficient. Only 38% of the main evaluated services meet the transparency criteria, compared to an average of 59% in the European Union.
A difference of 21 percentage points is highlighted in the new report of the OECD and EU SIGMA program, which analyzes the quality and availability of digital public services in the Western Balkans.
According to the report, the rapid expansion of electronic services in Albania has not always been accompanied by complete information for users about how procedures work.
This means that the possibility to submit an online application does not necessarily guarantee that the citizen has clear information about all the steps of the process, the waiting time, or how their personal data is used.
What is not sufficiently explained to users?
The European methodology for evaluating digital services takes into account several elements of transparency.
It analyzes whether the user is informed about the steps they need to follow during the application, processing deadlines, and the expected time to receive a response.
It is also assessed whether institutions explain how personal data is handled and whether they publish information about performance and service improvements.
In Albania, according to the OECD, these elements have not been uniformly integrated into electronic services.
The report links this shortcoming to the rapid pace of digital transformation, during which attention has been focused on completing procedures online, while informing users has not always received the same importance.
There are also services that meet high standards
The OECD’s assessment is not negative for all Albanian services.
The report highlights as a positive example the online vehicle tax declaration service.
In this case, the platform confirms the successful completion of each step, informs the user about the expected processing time, and sets the maximum deadline within which the administration must provide the service.
Additionally, data about the service’s performance is published, and error messages appear when the user enters incorrect information.
According to SIGMA, this example shows that more advanced transparency functionalities exist in the Albanian administration, but they have not been evenly distributed across all services.
Transparency, part of the standards for EU integration
The report notes that the European average of 59% also indicates that transparency remains an area where improvements are needed, but Albania is still at a lower level.
For countries aiming for EU membership, transparency is not only about publishing information online. It is part of the quality of public service and citizens’ right to understand how their requests and data are handled.
The OECD recommends that Western Balkan countries shift from focusing on the number of services available online towards quality assessment, full completion of procedures electronically, and their transparency.
For Albania, the next challenge is that improvements are not limited to adding new services, but also include clear information for citizens at every stage of the application process. /ekofin.al
