In September 1992, Italy was the warning example of European finance. The Italian lira was forced to exit the European Exchange Rate Mechanism, the currency suffered a sharp decline, and Rome faced the task of convincing investors that it was still able to meet its obligations.
What followed was more than three decades of budget austerity, a policy Italians continue to debate even today. Year after year, the state collected more revenue than it spent, not counting debt interest.
Economists call this a primary surplus. According to data from the International Monetary Fund, Italy has recorded a primary surplus in 28 out of 34 years since 1992.
Now, one of the largest banks in the world says that the rest of the Group of Seven (G7) countries will have to do the same.
“Every G7 member will have to follow the Italian model,” said Janet Henry, HSBC’s global chief economist, in a report published last week titled “Are We Becoming Italians?”.

Her argument is based on a simple calculation. When the interest rate a government pays on its debt remains higher than the rate of economic growth, the debt continues to rise relative to the gross domestic product (GDP), except when the government spends less than it collects in revenue before paying interest.
With high borrowing costs in developed economies, Henry expects this gap to continue to persist.
A lesson that Italy learned in the hardest way
Henry was careful not to portray Italy as an exemplary student.
“Italy is not a perfect model: its debt level remains high, but it has recorded a primary surplus for many consecutive years, initially forced by a severe currency and debt crisis in 1992,” she said.
According to her, the difference lies in the fact that Rome has continued this effort for decades, while other countries have barely begun.
“Unlike Italy, none of the other countries is on track to achieve a long-term fiscal adjustment,” Henry said.
She added that only countries that have felt pressure from bond markets, like the United Kingdom, have tried to manage their deficits over the past year.
Not even the United States escapes this problem. Henry referred to an assessment by the director of the U.S. Congressional Budget Office, the institution overseeing U.S. public finances, according to which stabilizing American debt solely through economic growth would require a nominal increase of 7-8% per year at current rates.
She also warned that the easy ways out of this situation have been closed. Governments cannot cut spending in the same way Greece and Portugal did after the eurozone crisis, while productivity growth thanks to artificial intelligence may not easily translate into higher tax revenues.
“Difficult political decisions lie ahead,” she said.

Only one G7 country spends less than it collects in revenue
The latest data from the International Monetary Fund show how isolated Italy’s position is.
According to the IMF’s October fiscal monitoring report, Italy is expected to register a primary surplus of 1% of GDP this year, which will increase to 1.2% in 2027. It is the only G7 economy expected to record such a result.
France is expected to have a primary deficit of 2.9% of GDP this year. Germany, long known as the fiscal discipline of the eurozone, is projected to register a primary deficit of 3.4%, while increasing spending on defense and infrastructure.
The United States is expected to record a primary deficit of 4.9%, Canada 2.6%, while Japan and the United Kingdom will each report around 1.2%.
How much other countries need to improve their finances remains a subject of debate. In an article published in March in the IMF’s journal “Finance and Development,” economist Zsolt Darvas estimated that France and the United States would need a primary surplus of 1.3% of GDP to stabilize their debt, while the United Kingdom would need a surplus of 1.8%.
For France, this would mean improving the budget balance by more than four percentage points of GDP. Darvas pointed out that Paris has reached the required level only six times over the past five decades.
However, Italy continues to bear the heaviest debt burden. The IMF expects its public debt to reach 137.9% of GDP this year, the highest level in the eurozone and above that of Greece, which is projected to be 136%. France stands at 118.5%.
Bond markets have already changed their stance.
Investors seem to have reached a conclusion similar to that of HSBC.
On Monday, at 13:26 Central European Time, 10-year Italian government bonds had a yield of 4.43%, while equivalent French bonds (OAT) had a yield of 4.93%.
This means that Rome is borrowing for a 10-year period at an interest rate half a percentage point lower than Paris. On Friday, the gap closed at 50 basis points, the most favorable level for Italy since at least 1999, according to TradingView data.
The turnaround has been rapid. At the beginning of 2025, Italy paid 34 basis points more than France. The two curves crossed in September 2025, and the gap has continued to widen since then.
Italy now borrows even more cheaply than the United Kingdom, where the yield on 10-year bonds is 5.35%, and the United States, where 10-year Treasury bonds have a yield of 5.12%.
Compared to Germany, which serves as a reference point for the eurozone, the difference between Italian BTP bonds and German Bund bonds is 106 basis points.
This difference measures the additional profit investors seek to sustain Italian debt instead of German debt. For France, the corresponding spread is 156 basis points, more than double the 71 basis points level with which it started the year.
Italy has not been immune to bond sales this year. Its spread widened from around 60 basis points at the end of February, as the war in the Middle East increased energy prices, inflation expectations, and borrowing costs across Europe.
Claus Vistesen and Melanie Debono, economists at the Pantheon Macroeconomics, expect this move to be reversed.
“We believe that the spread between Italian and German bonds will narrow next year, more than fully reversing the expansion recorded this year,” they said in a report published on Thursday. “We forecast this spread to reach 20 basis points by mid-2027, down from just over 100 basis points currently.”
Part of their reasoning is related to France. They argue that the country’s more serious fiscal problems, along with the uncertainty accompanying next year’s presidential elections, will push investors to turn to Italian bonds.
However, even in this case, relatively cheaper borrowing does not mean that Italian debt is cheap.
“Yields will remain high, just above 3%, keeping the costs of Italian government debt at high levels for now,” they said.
The budget in the election year tests the model
The biggest test for Italy could come from Rome itself.
The government of Giorgia Meloni approved the 2027 budget on October 28, a package worth around 26 billion euros, which is now being reviewed in Parliament.
A large part of the package consists of tax reliefs.
Only for the year 2027, the income threshold taxed at the 33% rate will be expanded for salaries up to 55,000 euros, up from the current 50,000 euros.
New private sector employees, born after 1997 and with incomes up to 28,000 euros, will pay a fixed tax of 1% on salary increases up to 2,500 euros. Salary increases resulting from the renewal of collective labor agreements will be taxed at a fixed rate of 5% for employees earning up to 33,000 euros.
Self-employed individuals will be able to benefit from the fixed-rate tax regime for turnover up to 100,000 euros, up from the current 85,000 euros.
The vehicle tax will be permanently removed for a vehicle insured with up to 80 kilowatts per owner, while mothers with two or more children and incomes up to 40,000 euros will receive 100 euros per month, tax-free.
To finance part of these measures, banks and insurance companies will face a three-point increase in profit tax over two years. Energy companies will pay a higher regional tax on business activities, while the tax on financial transactions will double, reaching 0.8%.
The Italian Court of Auditors, the institution that oversees public spending, told lawmakers on November 9 that many of the tax reliefs will end at the end of 2027 and that about 70% of the funding will not be repeated. This means that the financial burden will remain with the next Parliament.
The government’s own fiscal plan, published in October, foresees the deficit at 2.9% of GDP this year and rising to 3.4% in 2027, after including additional spending on defense and energy, allowed under European Union rules.
Debt is expected to increase slightly, reaching 138.5% of GDP next year.
An unpredictable electoral race
The budget is being published at a time when Italy is heading towards general elections, which must be held no later than the fall of 2027, while in Rome discussions about the possibility of early elections in the spring are intensifying.
The latest SWG poll for La7 television, published on November 9, ranked the center-left opposition at 44.9%, while Meloni’s center-right coalition at 44%. The difference between them is within the margin of error.
Meloni’s party, “Brothers of Italy,” remained the largest political force in particular, with 28.9% support, while 29% of respondents did not express a preference for any political force.
Pantheon Macroeconomics’ baseline scenario is that the governing coalition will survive after the elections. According to the institute, this is another reason why the spread between Italian and German bond yields is expected to remain narrow throughout 2027.
In 1992, Italy had no choice but to tighten its belt. Thirty-four years later, the rest of the G7 countries are being asked to do the same, precisely at a moment when Italy is tempted to ease its fiscal policies. / Adapted from Euronews, ekofin.al
