One of the most sensitive issues for freedom of expression and the functioning of democracy is the use of judicial processes as instruments of pressure against journalists, activists, civil society organizations, and individuals who expose issues of public interest. Such lawsuits, internationally known as SLAPP (Strategic Lawsuits Against Public Participation), can not necessarily be used to win a case in court, but to intimidate, financially exhaust, and hinder those exercising their right to information and expression.
It is precisely against this phenomenon that a new draft law proposed by the Council of Ministers, titled “On procedural measures and the protection of persons engaged in public participation from clearly unfounded lawsuits and abusive judicial procedures,” aims to intervene.
The initiative foresees the creation of a special legal mechanism to protect natural and legal persons facing legal proceedings due to their involvement in matters of public interest. It includes civil and commercial matters, with or without cross-border elements, aiming to also address cases where lawsuits are filed beyond national borders.
What is considered public participation and when can a lawsuit be abusive?
One of the main elements of the draft law is the broad definition of the concept of public participation. According to it, this category includes statements and activities related to the exercise of freedom of expression and information, artistic freedom, scientific research, assembly, and organization.
The defense also extends to preparatory, supportive, or auxiliary actions directly related to these freedoms, as long as they concern matters that present or may present public interest.
This includes topics such as human rights, public health, security, environment, climate, the activities of public persons in both the public and private sectors, issues reviewed by state institutions, as well as reports of corruption, fraud, or other violations.
The draft law stipulates that a judicial procedure is considered abusive when it does not genuinely aim to exercise or protect a right, but primarily aims to prevent, limit, or punish public participation.
To identify such cases, the court must consider several elements, including the disproportionate nature of the lawsuit, the existence of repeated proceedings by the same plaintiff, intimidating or threatening behavior, and the misuse of procedural means to delay the process.
This is an important point, as not every lawsuit against a journalist or activist is automatically considered abusive. The assessment belongs to the court, which must examine the purpose, circumstances, and manner in which the procedure was initiated and conducted.
Early dismissal of lawsuits and the 60-day deadline
One of the most important mechanisms introduced by the draft law is the possibility for the defendant to request the early dismissal of a clearly unfounded lawsuit.
According to the proposed provisions, this right can be exercised from the moment the complaint is notified.
The court must inform the defendant of this possibility, and after the request is submitted, the plaintiff is given the chance to present their objections.
An important element is also the burden of proof: the draft law stipulates that the plaintiff must prove the validity of the claim by presenting the facts and evidence supporting their claims.
If the court finds that the lawsuit is manifestly unfounded, it may dismiss it at the earliest possible stage of the process.
Furthermore, requests for guarantees of court costs and early dismissal of lawsuits should be examined with priority, while the court must decide within 60 days of their submission.
This mechanism aims to avoid one of the most severe effects of SLAPP lawsuits: the obligation of the defendant to spend months or years in a legal process, even when the claims against them are clearly unfounded.
The plaintiff may be required to deposit financial guarantees
Another innovation provided in the draft law is the possibility for the court, at the request of the defendant, to order the plaintiff to deposit a financial guarantee to cover court costs.
This guarantee may also include the costs of legal representation and is determined by the court, taking into account the circumstances of the case, the financial situation of the parties, and the need to ensure effective access to justice.
If during the process it turns out that the initial guarantee is insufficient, the defendant may request the establishment of an additional guarantee.
If the plaintiff does not deposit the guarantee within the deadline set by the court, the process may be terminated at the request of the defendant.
This provision aims to establish a protective mechanism against situations where a person is forced to bear significant legal costs due to a process initiated abusively.
A fine of up to 300,000 lek and compensation for the injured party
The draft law does not stop at dismissing lawsuits. It also foresees financial consequences for plaintiffs found to have filed clearly unfounded lawsuits or initiated abusive legal procedures against public participation.
According to Article 11, the court may order compensation for material and non-material damages caused to the defendant. It may also order the publication of the court decision, at the plaintiff’s expense.
Another measure is the administrative-procedural fine provided for in Article 12, which ranges from 50,000 to 300,000 lek.
The court may impose this fine primarily or at the request of the defendant, taking into account the nature and consequences of the violation, the plaintiff’s behavior, and the need to prevent the repetition of such procedures.
In addition, the plaintiff may be charged with all the defendant’s court costs, including attorney fees, except in cases where these are clearly excessive.
Protection even beyond Albania’s borders
Another important aspect of the initiative relates to the international dimension of SLAPP lawsuits.
The draft law also provides protective mechanisms in cases where a person residing or headquartered in Albania faces a judicial procedure in a third country due to their public participation.
Under these circumstances, Albanian courts may refuse recognition or enforcement of a decision issued by a court of a third country if they find that the lawsuit on which the decision was based was manifestly unfounded or that the procedure was abusive according to the criteria of this law.
Also, the affected person can apply to the competent court in Albania to seek compensation for damages and reimbursement of expenses.
This provision takes on special importance in a reality where investigative journalism, international organizations, and civil society activities often involve actors and interests that extend beyond a single jurisdiction. /ekofin.al
