The number of stores damaged during the weekend unrest in France has reached at least 3,000, double the figure reported just one day earlier.
However, insurance companies, which are expected to bear a large portion of the costs, still do not have an assessment of the damages caused.
France Assureurs, the French federation of insurance companies, told Euronews that its members are “fully mobilized to support the affected.”
It was unable to provide an initial assessment of the losses nor to indicate how many compensation claims had been filed so far.
Its crisis management team is working with public authorities across France following what the federation described as an “extremely violent incident.”
French financial markets record a decline, while the damage bill rises
On Sunday, Carrefour’s CEO, Alexandre Bompard, who also leads the retail trade federation FCD, estimated that around 1,500 stores were affected.
He said that the sector’s losses amounted to several hundred million euros.
By Monday, the figure published by the government had reached 3,000 stores.
Only the Carrefour network reported damage in 50 stores, including 20 of them that had been looted.
Financial markets were also under pressure on Monday. The French CAC 40 index closed the session down 1.1%, performing worse than the broader European index EURO STOXX 600, which fell by 0.9%.
Carrefour shares lost 2.2%, while the luxury group LVMH fell by 1.8%. A Louis Vuitton boutique in Marseille was among the stores that were broken into and looted over the weekend.
Shares of insurance companies also declined. AXA lost 1.3%, while the reinsurance company SCOR fell by 0.9% in Paris. In Milan, Generali lost 2.3%, while Unipol fell by 3.2%.
French government bonds were also put under selling pressure on Monday.
The yield on 10-year maturity French bonds rose by about eight basis points, reaching 4.94%. The yield on the corresponding German bonds increased by less than four basis points.
This pushed the gap between borrowing costs between France and Germany to around 148 basis points.
What do the 2023 unrest tell us about the cost of damages?
France has a recent precedent to assess how much such a weekend might cost.
The unrest that engulfed the country in June and July 2023 caused insured damages worth 793 million euros, according to data provided by France Assureurs to Euronews.
Insurance companies handled around 17,000 compensation claims, with an average value of approximately 46,600 euros each.
Two-thirds of the total amount, about 523 million euros, went to shops and commercial spaces. One quarter, approximately 200 million euros, was paid to local authorities, whose municipal buildings, schools, and buses were attacked.
The remaining 7% was related to vehicles.
However, even these figures did not reflect the full scale of the destruction.
A subsequent investigation by the French Senate estimated that the material damages were closer to 1 billion euros. Some losses were never declared, while others were only partially covered by insurance.
Comparison is especially important now, as the number of affected stores appears to be higher.
The French Chamber of Commerce and Industry (CCI France) counted around 2,500 businesses vandalized during the 2023 unrest. The figure published by the government for the past weekend has already exceeded this level.
The new French riot insurance scheme is not yet ready
France tried to address the security issues highlighted by the 2023 unrest through the 2026 budget law.
Legislation makes it mandatory to cover damages from riots in certain types of property insurance policies and creates a national fund to help insurance companies cope with large losses.
Insurance companies will finance the fund through contributions of up to 1.5% of the respective insurance premiums, while the state will offer guarantees of up to 4 billion euros per year.
But the scheme has not yet come into effect. It requires approval from the European Commission and an implementing decree from the government.
For businesses affected by this weekend’s violence, this means that compensation will depend on existing insurance contracts.
Insurance can cover damages, but what about lost sales?
Most French insurance policies for shops and buildings include coverage for “civil unrest and disorder,” according to France Assureurs.
This coverage usually includes damage from fire, theft, vandalism, and breaking shop windows. It also generally covers the installation of wooden panels to protect damaged stores and the payment of security guards needed in the days following attacks.
The problem arises when it comes to lost sales.
Compensation for the full or partial closure of a business depends on whether the contract includes additional coverage for the cessation of activity.
This insurance compensates for the loss of gross profit, not the value of lost sales, and is usually applied only when physical damages covered by the policy have forced the business to close.
Some contracts provide coverage even in cases where the business premises have not been damaged. However, this only applies “in the circumstances explicitly specified in the insurance policy,” the federation emphasized.
In general, the insured have five days to notify the insurance company. For some types of coverage, filing a police report is a prerequisite for receiving compensation.
The portion that the state will bear
French Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu stated on Monday that businesses affected by the unrest could benefit from the state support scheme for employees with reduced activity, known in France as partial activity, starting Tuesday.
He also asked local authorities to impose curfew hours in certain areas and said that a state of emergency would be declared “if necessary.”
President Emmanuel Macron rejected the resignation of Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez, while the number of arrests surpassed 2,400.
Every euro spent supporting businesses will weigh heavily on a budget expected to register a deficit of 5.4% of Gross Domestic Product (GDP) this year, while public debt reaches 119% of GDP.
And although the ultimate bill of the unrest is still unknown, one thing is becoming increasingly clear: the cost will go far beyond the shops that were attacked./Adapted from Euronews, ekofin.al
