The National Environment Agency issued 806 decisions for preliminary environmental impact assessments during 2023 and another 909 in 2024, but the evidence for their follow-up through monitoring is significantly more limited. According to the Supreme State Audit, in 2023 there were only 320 cases registered for reporting and in 2024 only 72, while the audit also identified few field verifications, lack of opinions from institutions, and low participation in public consultations.
The findings are part of the final report of the Supreme State Audit (KLSH) on the National Environment Agency and regional agencies, where the environmental impact assessment process for projects and activities requiring the respective approvals has been reviewed.
According to the report’s data, during 2023, 1,114 new applications for environmental impact assessment were submitted to the NEA, while the institution handled and resolved 1,536 cases with decision-making. Of these, 806 ended with decisions for preliminary EIA and six with decisions for in-depth EIA.
In 2024, the number of new applications increased to 1,161, while cases handled by decision reached 2,059. During this year, 909 decisions were issued for preliminary EIA and four for in-depth EIA.
For the period January–September 2025, 1,094 new applications were registered, while 2,404 cases were processed through decision-making. Of these, 396 ended with a decision for a preliminary EIA and only one with a decision for a deep EIA.
However, the Supreme State Audit (KLSH) finds that the number of decisions issued has not been accompanied by relevant evidence from subsequent monitoring.
According to the audit, decisions regarding preliminary EIA should be followed through reporting and monitoring after their entry into force, in accordance with the obligations set out in the legislation.
According to the database administered by AKM, only 320 cases were registered for reporting in 2023, compared to 806 decisions for preliminary EIAs.
For the year 2024, the cases considered for reporting were 72, compared to 909 decisions issued.
Meanwhile, for the year 2025, by the end of September, there are 13 cases considered for reporting compared to 396 decisions for preliminary EIAs. For this period, the six-month monitoring period after the decisions come into effect must also be taken into account.
The Supreme State Audit (KLSH) assesses that the discrepancy between the number of decisions and the cases identified for reporting indicates inaccuracies in the records and deficiencies in following up on active monitoring obligations.
Projects are reviewed even without the opinions of the responsible institutions
The audit report raises as an issue the way inter-institutional consultations are conducted for projects with environmental impact.
According to the Supreme State Audit (KLSH), in most procedures for environmental declarations and environmental impact assessments, the consulted institutions often did not provide an opinion.
In these cases, the lack of response has been treated as tacit approval, while the decisions are mostly formal and based on legal references.
Among the institutions required to provide opinions, depending on the nature of the project, are the municipalities, the National Agency of Natural Resources, the Ministry of Infrastructure and Energy, and the Water Resources Management Agency.
The Supreme State Audit (KLSH) has found concrete cases where project review procedures were conducted without the opinions of some of these institutions.
One case concerns the project for the construction of the Osmani HPP on the Zalli i Liconës stream, in Bulqizë, Dibra, with an installed capacity of 2 MW. According to the audit, in the preliminary EIA procedure for this project, the opinion of the National Agency of Natural Resources and the Dibër Municipality was missing.
Also, in the public consultation held on October 1, 2025, low participation was noted, while representatives of the structures responsible for forests and local self-government units were absent.
In another case related to a wind power plant project in the Qafa e Shullanit area, in the Municipality of Vau i Dejës, the Supreme State Audit (KLSH) notes that the municipality had expressed opposition to the development of the project until the relationship between the investor and the local unit was regulated.
Alongside shortcomings in inter-institutional consultations, the audit found that the number of field verifications by the working groups of the Regional Environmental Agencies is very low compared to applications for environmental declarations or preliminary EIAs.
According to the SSA, this weakens the possibility for decision-making to rely on concrete verifications of the project conditions and its potential impact on the territory.
In conclusion, KLSH assesses that the environmental impact assessment process is characterized by deficiencies in inter-institutional coordination, field verifications, and public participation.
For this reason, the institution recommends strengthening cooperation among the authorities reviewing the projects, increasing the number of risk-based field verifications, and improving public consultations. /ekofin.al

