Around 64 million lek have been paid for the construction of the water supply systems in the villages of Peshtan and Mezhgoran in the Tepelena Municipality, but the investment has not yet been put into operation. The Supreme State Audit has found that the works carried out have not produced the expected effect, as a key part of the water supply system has not been built, leaving the project unfinished.
According to the final audit report, the amount of 63,989,574.84 lek without VAT, paid for the works of this water supply system, is considered by the Supreme State Audit (KLSH) as an expense lacking economy, efficiency, and effectiveness. This is because, despite the completion of part of the infrastructure, the system was not functional at the time of the audit and had not fulfilled the purpose for which it was financed.
The investment is part of a broader contract for the construction of water supply networks in the villages of Nivicë, Rexhinë, Peshtan, and Mezhgoran, with a total value of 232.67 million lek including VAT. The contract was signed on April 26, 2021, with an initial implementation deadline of 150 calendar days from the handover of the construction site, but the works have been accompanied by repeated suspensions and project changes.
Residents’ objections and the project change
The biggest problems have appeared on the Peshtan–Mezhgoran segment, where residents have opposed the passage of the water supply line onto private properties.
According to the documentation reviewed by KLSH, the first suspension of the works was requested in October 2021. In January 2022, the contractor again reported obstacles from residents who claimed that the pipeline was passing through their properties. Another interruption occurred in February 2023, while the process was also affected by the procedures for obtaining the necessary permits.
Faced with these difficulties, the initial project has been revised. The works have focused on a part of the main line and storage infrastructure, while the completion of the water intake project from the source and the remaining elements has been postponed to a second phase.
But precisely the lack of a water intake facility has made the system non-functional, despite the funds spent.
KLSH assesses that this situation has led to ineffective use of public funds, as the constructed infrastructure cannot fulfill its function without completing the entire technical scheme of the water supply system.
Paid works, but not even completed on site
Besides the malfunctioning of the water supply system, the audit also identified problems with the volumes of reported and paid works.
For the Peshtan–Mezhgoran segment, the Supreme State Audit (KLSH) found an economic damage of 1,016,251 lek excluding VAT, as a result of inaccurately calculated works, overlapping volumes, and works that have not been proven to have been completed.
Among other things, the documentation revealed overlaps in the volumes of excavation and route filling, the inclusion of transportation expenses which were also accounted for in other items, as well as concrete works supporting the pipeline, the realization of which was not documented.
For the remaining part of the contract, related to the water supply to the villages of Nivicë and Rexhinë, an economic damage of 441,368 lek was also identified.
In total, the economic damage identified in both sub-facilities amounts to 1,457,619 lek without VAT.
This amount is distinct from the approximately 64 million lek value that the Supreme State Audit classifies as an ineffective expense for the Peshtan–Mezhgoran water supply system.
The audit also identified deficiencies in the technical documentation, including the lack of pressure evidence for the water supply lines and complete quality documentation for some materials used.
The Supreme State Audit demands accountability and the completion of the investment
In its final recommendations, the Supreme State Audit requests that the Municipality of Tepelena establish a special working group to identify the causes and persons responsible for the ineffective use of 63.99 million lek. The SSA also requests the pursuit of administrative and legal procedures to recover the economic damage identified from the unfinished works. /ekofin.al
