The basic medical check-up concession, known as the Check-up, has received around 902 million lek in payments for 489,132 unperformed check-ups during the period 2015–2025, while the application of VAT on the service has created an additional budget cost of 1.34 billion lek. These are two of the main findings of the Supreme State Audit, which has identified significant problems in financing, monitoring, and fulfilling the obligations of the concession contract.
According to the audit report on the implementation of the state budget for 2025, total payments to the concessionaire up to December 31, 2025, have reached 8.05 billion lek including VAT. Out of 4,366,140 controls financed during this period, 3,877,008 were carried out, while 489,132 were paid without being performed.
The contract foresaw a volume of 475,000 inspections per year, a level which, according to the Supreme State Audit, was only reached and exceeded in 2019. However, payments were made based on the minimum guaranteed volume, regardless of how many inspections were actually carried out.
Only during 2025, the state paid 35.32 million lek for 19,147 unperformed inspections. KLSH assesses that the financial mechanism of the contract did not ensure a balanced distribution of risk between the parties, as the financial consequences of failing to carry out the planned inspections were borne by the state.
VAT, 1.34 billion lek additional cost for the budget
According to the KLSH report, another issue relates to the fiscal treatment of the concession. The basic medical check-up service was invoiced with VAT, although it should have been treated as a supply exempt from this tax.
For the period 2015–2025, this invoicing method has resulted in an additional budget cost of 1.34 billion lek. In 2025 alone, the financial impact of VAT reached around 146 million lek.
Without the 20 laboratories stipulated in the contract, there are also problems with recording the analyses.
In addition to financial costs, the Supreme State Audit (KLSH) has identified deficiencies in the implementation of the investments planned by the concessionaire. According to the report, the obligation to establish and operate 20 laboratories across the entire country, which were part of the service model on which the winning offer was based, has not been fulfilled.
The audit highlights that the failure to realize this investment and the reduction of operational costs have not been reflected in a decrease in the service price. Meanwhile, contractual documents also found discrepancies in the initial investment value, which is presented at around 476.9 million lek in some annexes and 172 million lek in another annex.
Additionally, the Supreme State Audit (KLSH) has identified 491,621 cases of inspections carried out and paid for, for which the responses completed by doctors are not recorded in the electronic system. These cases should not be confused with the 489,132 unperformed inspections, as the audit treats them as two separate issues.
The lack of institutional control is another identified problem. According to the Supreme State Audit (KLSH), the Ministry of Health did not conduct monitoring of contract implementation during the period 2015–2022, while monitoring in subsequent years had deficiencies. The Project Administration Board was established for the first time only in 2022.
On the eve of the contract’s expiration, the audit also identified the absence of a drafted and approved plan for exiting the concession, although this obligation was stipulated in the agreement. /ekofin.al
